Lewis injury could end great career – but is he the greatest MLB?
October 16, 2012, 4:18 pm
The right-triceps tear that ended Ray Lewis’ season could also mark the end of a career that will place him in the highest level of inside linebackers, of players, period, in the history of football.
But how “highest?”
CSNChicago.com operatives have seen linebackers play since the very early 1960s and evaluated available film of others before that. From that a top-five list of the greats, with Lewis finishing…, well, check out the list. And yes, two of the top three middle linebackers of all time played in Chicago.
A qualifier: Understand that the middle linebacker position really didn't come into true existence until Bill George stood up from his nose-guard position and started looking around. So the sample size for MLB’s in particular is necessarily smaller than the overall pool of linebackers.
The runners-up: Chuck Bednariik (saw him play in my first-ever ‘live’ football game; thanks, Dad), Bill George, Sam Huff, Ray Nitscke, Chuck Schmidt, Mike Singletary 5. Jack Lambert, Pittsburgh
No way to argue with the rings. A lot of hype but when you watched closely and often, this was the ignition key behind Joe Greene, L.C. Greenwood and Dwight White. Singletary’s eyes were a force but the edge goes to Lambert’s teeth. Or lack of same. 4. Willie Lanier, Kansas City Chiefs
Lanier was a centerpiece in one of the great defenses of all time, a member of Chiefs team won the fourth Super Bowl. Lanier had the benefit of playing behind tackles Buck Buchanan and Curly Culp but he also intercepted 27 passes in a 10-year career.
He played at 6-1, 245 pounds, about the same size as Lewis. He was nothing less than one of the best football players on a championship team.
Lanier had the “misfortune” of playing in the time of Jack Lambert, who was piling up rings and getting more acclaim. He shouldn’t have. Lanier was better. 3. Brian Urlacher
Urlacher stands as one of the more polarizing parts of any discussion of great linebackers. One national media outlet pegged him as the most overrated player in the NFL; others rated him the best in the game, evidenced by his selection as Defensive Player of the Year in 2005 and fourth-place in 2006.
Consider this: In the defensive schemes of Dick Jauron and Greg Blache, based on front-four mastodons keeping offensive linemen controlled, Urlacher piled up 116 tackles, six sacks, three interceptions in 2001.
When Ted Washington was hurt most of 2002, Urlacher was “exposed”: 151 tackles, four-and-a-half sacks, seven passes broken up.
Along comes Lovie Smith and a scheme based on small, fast defensive linemen no bigger than Tommie Harris’ 290 for the most part. In 2005, Urlacher is Player of the Year with 121 tackles, six sacks, five passes broken up.
Where Urlacher loses style points is that he has never played with the Neanderthal gene. A lasting image of Urlacher is the laughing inside the helmet; he had some fun.
Urlacher in 2001 was running down Michael Vick (short distance). He was fast enough to “spy” Vick and Daunte Culpepper.
And as one longtime NFL personnel executive said in support of the ranking: “If you’re drafting, do you take Lanier or Urlacher? ‘54’ was a freak.”
He is also the third-greatest linebacker ever to play the game. 2 Dick Butkus
1. Ray Lewis
An incredibly close call between 51 and 52. I initially placed Butkus above Lewis, a tipping point being Butkus’ abilities in coverage. He played at close to Lewis’ 245 pounds but had a couple of inches on Lewis at 6-3.
Both defined not just the ferocity of their eras; anyone can scream and be nasty. They epitomized excellence at the game.
It’s difficult to put Butkus in some sort of understandable context. In 1967 he had 18 sacks, according to one study of film from before sacks were an official stat. He had five interceptions his 1965 rookie year and had 22 for his career, tied for 11th all-time in franchise history.
But Lewis willed the 2000 Baltimore Ravens to a Super Bowl win with quarterback Trent Dilfer in the role of Bill Wade as caretaker. And Lewis has 31 career interceptions plus more than 40 career sacks.
And here’s the thing: Lewis was in his 17th NFL season this year. Butkus had considerably less in front of him than Lewis (no Haloti Ngata, no Tony Siragusa, to name a couple) but he also was only able to get through nine seasons before the knee injuries finished him. Lewis didn’t have to contend with the crack-back blocks of Butkus’ era but to be as good as Lewis is/was for all these years…
Ray Lewis is simply the best linebacker the NFL has ever seen.
Tags: Mike Singletary
, Trent Dilfer
, Baltimore Ravens
, Chicago Bears
, Brian Urlacher
, Ray Lewis
, Dick Butkus
, Jack Lambert